Reg D vs Reg A+ vs Reg CF: Which Securities Exemption Should You Use?
Reg D is best for raising capital from accredited investors with minimal disclosure; Reg A+ allows up to $75 million from the general public with light SEC review; Reg CF enables crowdfunding from non-accredited investors but caps raises at $5 million. Choose based on your investor type, fundraisi
Reg D is best for raising capital from accredited investors with minimal disclosure; Reg A+ allows up to $75 million from the general public with light SEC review; Reg CF enables crowdfunding from non-accredited investors but caps raises at $5 million. Choose based on your investor type, fundraising target, and disclosure tolerance.
Key Differences at a Glance
| Feature | Regulation D (Rule 506) | Regulation A+ (Tier 1 & 2) | Regulation CF |
|---|---|---|---|
| Maximum Raise | Unlimited | $20M (Tier 1) / $75M (Tier 2) | $5 Million |
| Eligible Investors | Accredited only (506b) or any investor (506c) | General public (non-accredited allowed) | General public (non-accredited allowed) |
| General Solicitation | Prohibited (506b) / Permitted (506c) | Permitted (testing the waters) | Permitted via platform only |
| SEC Filing Required | Form D only (post-sale) | Form A (pre-sale review) | Form C (pre-sale review) |
| Disclosure Requirements | Minimal to moderate | Detailed financials & narrative | Detailed financials & narrative |
| Time to Market | 2-4 weeks | 2-3 months | 2-3 months |
| Cost | $500-$5,000 | $20,000-$100,000+ | $5,000-$30,000 |
| 2023 Market Usage | ~$150+ billion raised annually | ~$150 million raised | ~$1.3 billion intended raises |
Regulation D Explained
Regulation D is the dominant framework for private capital raises in the United States. It provides an exemption from SEC registration for offerings that meet specific conditions under Rule 506. Companies can raise unlimited capital, making it the go-to choice for startups, growth-stage companies, and mature businesses seeking private investment.
Rule 506(b) restricts sales to accredited investors—individuals with net worth exceeding $1 million or annual income above $200,000 ($300,000 for married couples)—plus up to 35 non-accredited investors if they meet sophistication standards. Critically, Rule 506(b) prohibits general solicitation or advertising. You cannot post on social media, run Google ads, or publicly announce your raise. Investors typically come through your network, angel investors, venture capital firms, or referrals.
Rule 506(c), adopted in 2013, flips this dynamic by permitting general solicitation and advertising to accredited investors only. This rule requires verification that all investors are genuinely accredited—a more rigorous burden than the "reasonable belief" standard under 506(b). Many issuers now use 506(c) when they want public marketing but must confirm every investor's accreditation status.
Reg D requires minimal SEC involvement. You file a Form D within 15 days of the first sale, but the SEC does not pre-approve the offering. Disclosure requirements depend on the number and type of investors but are far lighter than Reg A+ or Reg CF. For accredited-only rounds, you may provide basic materials; for mixed audiences, financial statements become necessary. The speed-to-market advantage is substantial: most Reg D offerings launch within 2-4 weeks.
Regulation A+ Explained
Regulation A+, introduced as part of the JOBS Act in 2015, created a "mini public offering" framework allowing companies to raise up to $75 million annually without a full SEC registration. This regulation democratizes fundraising by permitting non-accredited investors to participate, dramatically expanding the potential investor pool.
Reg A+ has two tiers. Tier 1 caps raises at $20 million in a 12-month period and has relaxed disclosure rules. Tier 2 permits up to $75 million but requires substantially more rigorous financial reporting, audited statements, and ongoing compliance obligations. Both tiers allow "testing the waters"—companies can gauge investor interest through a preliminary offering statement before full SEC review, unlike traditional public offerings.
The SEC revi
Reg A+ enables advertising and public marketing. Companies can use social media, press releases, and digital campaigns to reach investors, though all claims must align with the filed offering circular. The regulatory framework resembles a scaled-down IPO: companies receive a qualified offering statement, securities trade on secondary platforms (though liquidity remains limited), and issuers face annual reporting obligations. Despite these advantages for investor access, actual market uptake has been modest—only $150 million raised in 2019, far below initial projections.
Regulation Crowdfunding Explained
Regulation Crowdfunding (Reg CF) enables companies to raise up to $5 million annually from any investor—accredited or non-accredited—through registered intermediary platforms such as SeedInvest, Wefunder, or StartEngine. This framework was designed to democratize early-stage investing and provide non-traditional access to high-growth opportunities.
Reg CF requires issuers to file a Form C with the SEC and post the offering exclusively on a registered funding portal. The platform handles investor communications, payment processing, and escrow arrangements. Companies must disclose detailed financial information, business plans, use-of-proceeds, and risk factors. The SEC reviews submissions before campaigns launch, typically taking 2-3 weeks.
A unique feature is the all-or-nothing funding model used by many platforms. If the target is not reached within a specified campaign period (usually 45 days), all investor funds return automatically. This reduces the risk that a company raises only partial capital and must manage an underfunded operation. However, this structure also creates pressure: if you miss your goal by even $1, you receive nothing.
Investment limits cap non-accredited investors at 10% of annual income or net worth (whichever is greater), up to $107,000 per year. Accredited investors have no per-transaction limits. Annual reporting obligations are lighter than Reg A+ but more involved than Reg D. Companies must file annual updates, respond to investor inquiries, and maintain financial records.
Despite the regulatory framework, Reg CF has generated approximately $1.3 billion in intended raises, though actual capital raised fell short. About 90% of Reg CF offerings are conducted through funding portals, creating a concentrated ecosystem with platform fees typically ranging from 5-8% of raised capital.
Head-to-Head Comparison
Investor Access & Network Requirements
Reg D is network-dependent. You need existing relationships, credibility in investment circles, or connections to institutional investors and angels. If you lack these networks, raising capital becomes exponentially harder. Reg A+ and Reg CF level the playing field by enabling public marketing and attracting investors outside your immediate circle. Non-accredited investors gain access to early-stage opportunities previously reserved for the wealthy. However, this democratization comes with regulatory overhead and lower capital amounts.
Speed & Time to Capital
Reg D is fastest. From concept to first investor check, expect 2-4 weeks if your materials are ready. Reg A+ and Reg CF both require SEC pre-approval, extending timelines to 2-3 months. If you're in a time-sensitive situation—competitors fundraising, a market window closing—Reg D's speed advantage is significant. The tradeoff: you need accredited investors ready to commit, and you cannot publicize broadly.
Disclosure Burden & Cost
Reg D has minimal disclosure costs. Filing a Form D costs a few hundred dollars, and legal fees range from $1,000-$5,000. Reg A+ Tier 2 and Reg CF both require detailed financial statements, auditor involvement, and comprehensive legal review. Tier 2 offerings routinely cost $50,000-$150,000+ in professional fees. Reg CF typically costs $5,000-$30,000. For bootstrapped or early-stage companies, Reg D's lower cost structure is a major advantage.
Capital Raising Potential
Reg D is unlimited. Companies regularly raise $10 million, $100 million, or more through Rule 506(c). Reg A+ caps out at $75 million annually under Tier 2. Reg CF maxes at $5 million. If you have massive capital needs or institutional investors ready to commit large checks, Reg D is the only option. For smaller rounds under $5 million, all three work, but Reg D's lack of ceiling matters if you exceed expectations and want to keep the raise open.
Secondary Market & Liquidity
Reg D securities are strictly private. Investors cannot trade their stakes on secondary markets; exits depend on acquisition, IPO, or negotiated buybacks. Reg A+ allows trading on alternative trading systems, theoretically enabling liquidity over time. Reg CF securities remain illiquid, though some platforms are developing secondary marketplaces. For investors seeking eventual liquidity without waiting for a company exit, Reg A+ has an edge. For founders, illiquidity under Reg D and Reg CF preserves cap table simplicity.
When to Choose Each Regulation
Choose Reg D If:
- You have a strong network of accredited investors or institutional relationships
- You need to raise capital quickly (within weeks)
- You want to minimize legal and compliance costs
- Your capital needs exceed $5 million
- You prefer a private raise without public disclosure
- You have institutional investors, VCs, or angels ready to commit large checks
Choose Reg A+ If:
- You want to raise $20-75 million and reach non-accredited investors
- You're comfortable with SEC pre-approval and 2-3 month timelines
- You have a compelling story that resonates with retail investors
- Your business model works at a larger scale and can justify $50,000-$150,000+ in professional costs
- You want potential secondary market trading to improve investor appeal
- You're a later-stage company with audited financials and clear growth metrics
Choose Reg CF If:
- You need to raise under $5 million
Part of Guide
About the Author
AIN Editorial Team