SEC Plan to Drop Internal Control Audits Draws Pushback

    TL;DR: The SEC proposed in May to extend the exemption from Sarbanes Oxley's outside audit of internal controls, and Accounting Today reports about 81% of public companies would be exempt. Critics wa…

    ·5 min read
    Reviewed by Jeff Barnes — CEO of Angel Investors Network · MBA · $1B+ in Capital Formation
    Workers seen from behind inspect a machined part at a steel table on a quiet factory production line lit by daylight.
    TL;DR: The SEC proposed in May to extend the exemption from Sarbanes-Oxley's outside audit of internal controls, and Accounting Today reports about 81% of public companies would be exempt. Critics warn financial statements could become less reliable. The exposure sits in smaller public companies and recent IPOs, including the ones private holders exit into.

    The rule at issue is Section 404(b) of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, known as SOX, the law Congress passed after accounting scandals at Enron and WorldCom. It requires an outside auditor to attest to the effectiveness of a company's internal control over financial reporting, according to the CLS Blue Sky Blog. Smaller and newer public companies have long been exempt, and the SEC proposed extending that exemption in May 2026. No source here reports that the proposal has been adopted.

    Accounting Today reported on November 12 that federal regulators and stock exchanges are pushing to reduce corporate audit mandates, and that the proposal is drawing objections.

    What would actually change?

    The independent check on a company's internal controls would go away for more companies. Everything else stays, as the table shows.

    RequirementWhat it coversUnder the proposal
    Section 404(a)Management reports how effective its internal controls are and lists material weaknessesStill applies to all public companies
    Section 404(b)An outside auditor attests to those controlsExemption extended to more companies
    Financial-statement auditAn audit of the reported numbersStill required, even for exempt companies

    The middle row is the one in play. Section 404(a) requires management of all publicly traded companies to disclose the effectiveness of their internal controls, per Knowledge at Wharton. Companies exempt from 404(b) still undergo a financial-statement audit, so the exemption reduces the scope of audit work rather than eliminating auditing, according to the CLS Blue Sky Blog.

    What do critics say it could cost investors?

    The sharpest data point comes from the SEC's own analysis of the 2012 JOBS Act, the Jumpstart Our Business Startups Act, which exempted IPOs with less than $1 billion in annual revenue from internal control audits. A Knowledge at Wharton discussion of that analysis says firms that went public after the Act and used the exemption were 1.5 times more likely to restate their financial statements than their peers. Their restatement rate was 13.5%, compared with 8.5% for the peer group.

    The SEC concedes a version of the point. Per the CLS Blue Sky Blog, the agency acknowledged that without the auditor's attestation, financial statements may become less reliable and the cost of capital could rise. Accounting Today's report adds a warning that there is a risk of losing ground by rolling back the SOX requirements.

    What is the case for the exemption?

    Cost is the main argument. The SEC estimates the average annual savings from forgoing an internal control audit at $210,000, made up of $100,000 in audit fees and $110,000 in internal costs, as Knowledge at Wharton describes the SEC's analysis.

    The agency also says lower compliance expenses "may allow registrants to redeploy freed up resources toward productive investment and growth opportunities," as quoted by the CLS Blue Sky Blog. For a company that cannot raise more outside financing, every dollar spent on audit fees is a dollar it cannot invest. That is a fair argument, and it is why the fight is not one-sided.

    What does this mean for an accredited investor?

    If your public holdings are mostly large companies, little may change for you. The exposure sits in smaller public companies and recent IPOs.

    Say you hold a venture position that may go public. The company could list with no outside auditor vouching for its controls, and you would be reading its numbers with less independent verification behind them. Verify before you trust is the whole discipline here, and the attestation is one of the few places someone else does the verifying for you.

    AIN's coverage of SEC semi-annual reporting and IPO exits looks at another rule change that affects how much information you get after a listing. The SEC private markets retail proposal points in the same deregulatory direction. For what happens when verification fails, see SEC private placement enforcement. Readers sorting out who qualifies for these deals can start with the SEC accredited investor definition.

    Nothing here is a recommendation about any security.

    Common mistakes

    Treating the exemption as the end of auditing is the easy error. Exempt companies still get a financial-statement audit, and management still has to report on its own controls.

    People also tend to read the 81% figure as proof that most of the market is about to lose oversight. The figure counts companies, and Accounting Today's summary does not say how much market value those companies represent, so it tells you little about your large-cap exposure.

    A third trap is ignoring your private holdings. A company that plans an IPO should be asked now what its controls look like, because the answer shapes how much you can verify once it lists.

    FAQ

    What is Section 404(b) of Sarbanes-Oxley?

    It requires an outside auditor to attest to the effectiveness of a company's internal control over financial reporting, according to the CLS Blue Sky Blog. Smaller and newer public companies have long been exempt from it.

    How is Section 404(a) different?

    Section 404(a) has management disclose how effective its internal controls are and list any material weaknesses, per Knowledge at Wharton. Section 404(b) is the separate audit of those controls.

    Is the SEC proposal a final rule?

    No. The CLS Blue Sky Blog says the SEC proposed extending the exemption in May 2026, and none of the sources here reports adoption.

    One thing to do today

    If you hold a private company that could list in the next few years, ask the founder or fund manager whether its auditor would be asked to attest to internal controls after an IPO. That answer tells you how much independent checking you will have once the shares trade. If you want rule changes like this explained as they land, the free AIN briefing sends them to you.

    Educational content only. Not investment, tax, or legal advice. Not an offer or solicitation to buy or sell securities. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Private-market investments are illiquid and involve risk of loss, including total loss of capital. Consult qualified advisers. Angel Investors Network is not a broker-dealer or investment adviser.

    Looking for investors?

    Browse our directory of 750+ angel investor groups, VCs, and accelerators across the United States.

    Share
    J

    About the Author

    Jeff Barnes, MBA